论生育假反歧视保护规定的司法适用

    On Judicial Application of Anti-discrimination Protection Regulations for Maternity Leave

    • 摘要: 中国生育假反歧视保护规定在司法实践中面临适用基础不足、适用标准不一、适用路径不当等问题,由此弱化劳动者因生育假遭受不利待遇时的权益保障,影响劳动者的生育意愿与职业发展,影响生育休假制度的具体运行。作为生育休假权的实质性保障条款,生育假反歧视保护规定有别于生育保护的基准性规范,通过公法保护请求权与债法待遇请求权实现相应的权利救济。该规定以生育休假权的平等保护为价值取向,其适用标准可以概括为区别对待标准、合理便利标准与实质不利标准。司法裁判应重点审查劳动者不利待遇与生育休假间的因果关系,综合运用近因原则、最小因果测试、动机审查等判断方法,其中劳动者同意与业务必要性可以成为除外免责事由。

       

      Abstract: In judicial practice, China’s anti-discrimination protection regulations on maternity leave face difficulties in application, such as insufficient application foundation, inconsistent application standards, and improper application paths. This exacerbates the discrimination dilemma caused by maternity leave among workers in practice, thereby affecting their willingness to give birth and their career development. The independent application basis of the anti-discrimination protection provisions for maternity leave is reflected in its substantive protection function for the right to maternity leave, and corresponding rights remedies are achieved through the protection of the right to request and the right to request debt treatment in public law. This regulation should be guided by the equal protection of the right to maternity leave, and its applicable standards can be summarized as differential treatment standards, reasonable convenience standards, and substantive disadvantage standards. The application path of this regulation should mainly focus on the causal examination between the unfavorable treatment of workers and maternity leave and conduct specific analysis from the principle of proximate cause, minimum causality, and motivation examination. Among them, the consent of workers and the necessity of business can be exempted from liability.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回
    Baidu
    map